Jump to Navigation
Over 20 Years Experience Handling all Injury, Insurance & Disability Claims

Lake Tahoe Bad Faith Insurance Law Blog

Long Term Disabiltiy Insurance Claim Helpful Hints

While there is a tsunami of information available at the push of a button detailing the difficulties of obtaining group (ERISA governed) long term disability insurance benefits, here's a few practical tips that will help under certain circumstances.  The singular circumstance of note for this brief discussion is that you have made an application for social security disability benefits.  (Hopefully it was successful.)  A surprising amount of beneficial information can come from that application and Hearing (if one is held).  You should make every effort to obtain the complete SSD file to include in your claim file (or administrative record) in your long term disability insurance claim. 

Very persuasive documentation can come from any written opinion by the Social Security Hearing Officer, which will provide opinion in favor of disability, well supported by medical and vocational information.  The SSD file also often contains a more complete medical record that the LTD insurance claim file.  It should be placed in its entirety (don't worry about duplication) in the LTD insurance file.  Also, the SSD file may contain a detailed report from a medical exam (where the doctor did in fact  examine you), with a well reasoned opinion supporting a work disability.  This can be crucial in your LTD insurance file.  Excellent vocational analysis by a vocational expert additionally may be in the SSD file, and absolutely should be provided to your LTD insurance company so that the vocational reality can not be ignored by your LTD insurer. 

Another possible gem in the SSD file may be a complete audio recording of the Hearing, where you, the SSD examining doctor and perhaps the vocational expert all testified.  This is the perfect opportunity to get your own spoken testimony into the record in the LTD appeal and federal lawsuit.  It may well be your only opportunity to get your own testimony concerning your disease or injury and its effect on your ability to work before the federal judge, since live testimony and generally even deposition testimony, is precluded from long term disability insurance federal court cases. 

Don't miss the wealth of supporting documentation (and perhaps live testimony) available in your SSD file, generally at no cost, that absolutely should be in your long term disability claim file in order to better your chances of a successful appeal of a denial of LTD benefits.  Best regards, as always, Randy Noah

ERISA Long Term Disability Insurance Law Practice Holiday Greeting

Best to all for Easter and Passover.  A great deal of work and new issues in long term disability insurance cases and claims.  I am short of time this week before leaving for the holiday weekend, but will hopefully update a few disability cases and insurance issues in the next week or two.  As always, please do not hesitate to ask questions related to long term disability insurance claims, or post comments on any previous postings.  Randy Noah

Long Term Disability Insurance Attorney Updates

Half way through March, 2012, already.  St. Paddy's just a few days away, and one of the wonderful marriages of Saturday with a Holiday dedicated to the serious study of Guiness.  Not much can improve on that thought, but I'll try anyway.

In the ongoing day to day litigation of long term disability insurance claims more of the usual suspects themes from the purveyors of LTD insurance.  Pre-existing condition exclusion is still alive and well.  Currently battling the insurance carrier's general pre-existing categories of medical conditions or symptoms, such as headaches, as opposed to really looking at a new medical diagnosis.  This particular claim will help to better understand how far an insurance company can go to claim pre-existing condition exclusion for rather general symptoms, as opposed to a closer examination of the diagnosed condition giving rise to the symptom.  As the claim goes forward from the admistrative LTD appeal to the lawsuit, I will update the findings and conclusions to this important aspect of long term disability insurance claims (pre-existing condition exclusions, that is).

Here's one I haven't seen in quite a long time, "contract recision."  It goes like this.  LTD insurance applicant with severely disabling renal disease cannot realistically be denied benefits, although the record requests go on and on for about six months.  Finally, being forced to make a decision on the case the insurer cancels the entire policy, claiming the applicant did not list a hospitalization in the year prior to his qualification for the insurance policy (this in not a pre-existing condition case).  Therefore, the insurance company has the legal right to rescind (cancel) the policy for failure to disclose material information that may have led their underwriting department to reject the insurance application.  Contract law does actually allow for this in certain situations, and as long as the recision occurs within a certain period of time, for example within two years of the issuance of the policy.  The interesting part of this particular case is that the applicant never filled out or signed the application.  It was done following a brief phone call by the sales agent.  The applicant never saw the application and has no memory of even being asked about past hospitalization.  I'll update the progression of this claim.

What else?  As always, more and more "no (or insufficient) objective medical evidence of limitiations and restrictions."  What can you do about this most common reason for denial of long term disability insurance claims?  Do all you can to have your medical providers document your condition, your limitations and your need to be off work due to your medical condition.  All medical records should be sent to the insurance company that have any bearing on your disabling condition.  This is tricky, but anything your employer may be willing to submit to the insurer, noting that with your medical condition you are not able to perform all of the required duties of your job, will be of immense value to your claim.  Employers, however, are extremely reluctant to have any involvement for fear of some type of violation of a myriad of state and federal employment laws.

Otherwise, the year marches forward, although it seems we have traveled back from a very early spring to winter (photo attached of the so much delayed snow at Tahoe).  The work on the highly anticipated (by me) conference room at the Tahoe office (the construction zone also visible in the attached photo) View image continues.  I am ever hopeful that by mid-summer all work will be done, which will include the video conference/phone capability in the new conference room.  It will be nice to be able to video conference with clients and potential clients (and anybody with questions) from the new facilities.  Soon.  Don't hesitate to contact me with any questions, comments or critique.  Happy St. Patrick's Day, Randy Noah

A Few Notes From A Long Term Disability Insurance Law Practice

Getting to the end of February, 2012, and barely a taste of winter in the Sierra Nevada Mountains.  I know it's not the driest winter on record, but certainly the least snow, most sun and warmest I've seen in 25 years of experiencing Tahoe winters.  There is an upside to endless, beautiful, spring weather with about a total of 30 minutes of snow shoveling and care free winter driving.  But I think the resident flora and fauna are not going to tolerate such an aberration in climate as well as the human species.  Skiers and ski resorts are decidedly displeased with Mother Nature.  In a severely recessed local economy the weather report has been bleaker than the business section of the local newspaper.  Oh well, complaining apparently has very little impact on tomorrow's weather, so might as well keep the snow shoes in the closet and enjoy another pleasant hike through the uncovered forest trails.  Now if winter hibernates again next year, we may have to have a more serious discussion about the climate.

As mentioned above the local economy's pulse is near a flatline (positive note:  there are decided signs of an increase in commercial construction in the South Tahoe area in the last few months).  The fallout from a five year decline in property value that evaporates nearly 50% of property value is hard to grasp.  So "they" say the economy is on a steady march to higher ground.  But at ground zero on Main Street it's still a matter of week to week financial existence, with job and housing insecurity a constant fact of life.  

Editorial Opinion:  It may be time for the Tahoe Basin to begin modeling its future more like Yosemite and Yellowstone than Reno.  Lake Tahoe is a natural wonder and an unoffical National Park.  A very sustainable future for the local population and the stunning environment can result from embracing this reality.... Now back to the regularly scheduled blogging.

This may sound all too familiar to anyone who has found their way to this blog because they have been denied long term disability benefits.  It's the acute suffering and financial need of nearly all of my clients, and people simply calling for advice, that keeps me dedicated to the single practice area of working on behalf of disability insurance applicants.

More on the local environment, economy and long term disability insurance claims and law in coming posts.  Be Happy, Randy Noah

A Long Term Disability Insurance Law Practice At Lake Tahoe

The law practice focusing on long term disability insurance benefits denials continues every day, but it's also rewarding to take a look outside every now and then.  While the Lake Tahoe region is a natural wonder in every season, this winter is remarkable for the extraordinary lack of snow, shown in these several photos.  While my photography is anything but remarkable, it's worth capturing the scenery, given that this site has seldom been seen in mid-January in the Northern Sierra Nevada mountains.  Almost a complete lack of snow.  However, as this is being written, winter snowfall has finally begun.  If the forecasted feet of snow is realized, it should make for fun, contrasting photos. 

More to report with long term disability insurance denials and ERISA in the next update

The forest near the Angora Ridge, site of the Angora fire.  View image.

Lake Tahoe uncovered in January.  View image.

Glass like ice and brown mountains at 7000 feet.  View image.

A New Year Of Long Term Disability Insurance Triumhs And Tribulations

Happy New Year to all.  So off we go into 2012.  Seems that rust and Unum (or Met Life, or CIGNA, or AETNA, or Sun Life etc.) never sleep.  Challenges right out of the gate include many of the usual suspects. 

Pre-existing condition denials, although entirely new medical conditions lead to disability post employment.  How pre-existing condition denials such as the ones on which I am currently working unfold will be reported in 2012.

Lack of objective medical evidence of disability.  It may be a New Year, but long term disability insurers (most specifically in ERISA cases) never tire of this one. There is perhaps some gathering light in the long, dark night of this LTD denial favorite as more federal courts find "lack of objective medical evidence" is simply a decision to ignore the findings of treating doctors and statements of the actual insured person.  Many courts are growing increasingly skeptical of cursory denial of long term disability insurance claims based on captive medical reviewers.  I'll try to report more on this trend based on my own cases throughout this year.

Here's a thought-to-be-extinct basis for denial brought back in 2012 from the past:  You were able to work on the last day of your employment, and your LTD insurance coverage ended on the day you left work, therefore your claim for disability technically begins the day after you stopped working when you were no longer covered under group LTD insurance.  Gotcha.  We'll see if one particular court in Northern California agrees with Sun Life.

Hope for 2012?  Or the end of the world.  I'll go with the positive viewpoint.  I do see increasing skepticism by the courts at the perfunctory and cursory denials of long term disabiity insurance.  I'll keep trying to fertilize this skepticism and see if it grows any real fruit.

2011 saw some growth in the infant long term disability insurer/administrator as fiduciary reasoning.  There were a few plaintiff-insured victories in court based on this theory, which is a complicated legal theory.  I'll try to monitor the progress of this line of reasoning in 2012, and try to boil the hard to understand theory into a plain language paragraph in a blog post.  It's hopeful, but too early to accurately say if the fiduciary theory is going to improve the odds getting denied long term disability insurance claims reversed and reinstated. 

All in all, 2012 should be a year of steady progress in bringing fair and just results back to long term disability insurance claims.

Where's the snow?  Where's winter?  Not at Lake Tahoe.  I'll post some pictures of a very brown winter wonderland later this month.  One bonus is very rare, thick, glass like ice on the lakes at high elevation in the Sierra Nevadas.  Makes for a unique ice fishing experience.  Regards, Randy Noah

Seasons Greetings

Wishing everybody the happiest holidays and a wonderful New Year!  Randy NoahView image

Long Term Disability Insurance Claims: A Few Small Stocking Stuffers.

"Happy Holidays" and "ERISA governed long term disability insurance benefit claims" go together about as well as oil and water.  But, in the spirit of the Holidays, just a few small packages of hope to note at this time of year.

-   A small trend with appellate courts recognizing that insurance company medical reviews by insurance doctors are not reliable or necessarily reasonable.

-  A trend towards increased settlement, or "buy out" offers, to long term disability insurance benefit recipients that are almost reasonable.  The catch:  You need to have an attorney approve the agreement, and the insurance company will only pay $250 for the attorney review.  An interesting approach by Big Insurance to carve out any meaningful legal assistance to LTD claimants, but if a few people in desperate need of financial relief are helped, long live the trend.

- Appellate courts willingness (again) to state that undercover surveilance films are almost always of no meaningful assistance in determining disability, and over reliance on undercover video is reason to reverse an insurance company denial of benefits.

- Hope for homeowners about to lose their homes.  A government program that seems to be working (maybe).  If you are on unemployment and you cannot make your home payments there is a program administered by the states using federal monies that will make mortgage payments (up to a cap) for the time you are on unemployment benefits.  While this has limited application to long term disability insurance benefit claimants (and so many of you are losing your homes), there may be a few who can take advantage of this program.  Any help for even a few disabled workers is welcomed.

- Bargain value wines continue to improve in quality.  And I've noticed wonderful macro brewery Canadian beers going on sale at outstanding prices.  Just in time for the Holidays and keeping the 99% spirits bright!  Cheers, Randy Noah

Long Term Disability Insurance Attorney During The Holidays

Belated happy Thanksgiving.  Always a refuge of feast, family and festivity in the rush to the end of the year work and celebrations.  In Northern California and Lake Tahoe it's been a long extended Fall season, with winter reluctant to arrive.  Lots of sun, some cool, some cold, some mild, but little rain or snow.  Not even sure if the bears at Tahoe have seriously thought of hibernation yet. The coyotes have been a bit more visible, probably taking advantage of easier hunting of various rodents.  They know it'll get considerably more challenging when several hundred inches of snow blankets the forests and mountains.  Best to fatten up now. 

Unfortunately, this time of year serves to underscore the hardship of so many individuals with work disabilities who have been denied long term disability insurance benefits.  Anecdotal evidence from my practice suggests an ever increasing number of disabled and uninsured are at critical risk for losing their housing, along with health care.  And even more unfortunately, little can be done to lessen the extreme hardships many are enduring.  What I  can do is respond quickly to every client concern, and always be available to talk to clients and explain the claims and federal court appeal process for a long term disability insurance (erisa) case.  A realistic understanding and knowledge of the legal process provides a basis for making many of hard decisions required when  facing a work disability and income crisis. 

Those of you currently involved in a long term disability insurance claim, where benefits have been denied, are gaining an understanding of the grossly uneven playing field on which you find yourself with the insurance company or large corporation.  I have focused on this area of law for some years now, and have wondered how extreme can it get.  Just how far will an insurance company push the very forgiving limits of ERISA?  The blind individual should be able to learn brail within 12 months and be fully fit for sedentary employment.  Really?  How about someone who is dead?  Are they also fit for sedentary employment?  I'll find out and let you know in future posts.  My client, very ill with numerous serious conditions, was on long term disability benefits for some years, and then cut off, since it was reasonsed that she was actually malingering so she could stay home and take care of her children.  Sedentary employment would be well within in her capacity according to the insurance company doctors.  So big insurance company sends her their final benefits denied letter and she dies just days later of medical complications.  More to come on this later. 

If you have any useful advice or resources for disabled people facing eviction or forclosure, please feel free to contact me so I can pass it along to disabled individuals I work with.  Regards, Randy Noah

A Long Term Disability Insurance Claims Law Practice Illustrated

A few photos follow to partially illustrate daily life in the long term disability insurance claims practice.

View image   Rusty, the main office security system

View image  The South Lake Tahoe Office can be a bit drafty

View image  Oh crap, gotta find the snow shovel

View image The neighbors can get ornery

View image Fishing break

Subscribe To This Blog’s Feed Testimonials
Office Location

Law Office of P. Randall Noah
21 Orinda Way, Suite C, #316
Orinda, CA 94563

Toll Free: 866-906-9428
Phone: 925-402-4529 / 510-406-9418 (Cell)

Fax: 925-253-5542

Tahoe Office
1023 Carson Avenue
South Lake Tahoe, CA 96150

Mailing address: P.O. Box 9421
South Lake Tahoe, CA 96158

Email | Get directions

VISA MasterCard Discover Network

Skype toll free video conference available

Skype